Removing a Stuck or Broken Tub Drain

What to do when drain wrench or extractor tools can't do the job...

Old drain ring is stuck and cannot be removed with typical tools (drain extractor or drain wrench).
Drain wrench won't remove drain, e.g., because cross-shaped base of drain is broken.
Drain extractor tool won't loosen the drain, e.g., too tight or glued in place.

Insert an old flathead screwdriver or a cold steel chisel into a groove, and hammer in the direction required to rotate loosen the ring (counterclockwise).
Repeat in the opposite grove, tapping in the opposite direction.
Using a mallet to tap the overall drain assembly can help to loosen up putty or glue beneath.
Hair dryer heating and cooling cycles may also be useful to utilize expansion and contraction.

Note: we both use and promote Amazon and Home Depot products for widespread availability and quick fixes! See below for more information.

Drain Extractor (knurled plug and nut, useful for a drain without or with broken internal crossmembers)

Drain Wrench (useful for a drain with intact crossmembers down inside the drain)

Dremel rotary tool (used to cut grooves into the drain if other tools fail. This is a must-have for every DIYer).

The information on this site is provided as-is, and this site makes no guarantees.
Visitors assume all risks; this site does not guarantee accuracy or safety.
Visitors should follow safety precautions and best practices, consulting professionals if necessary.
The creators are not licensed professionals and no professional-client relationship is formed.
Note that some repairs may void warranties or cause further damage.
Outcomes are not guaranteed and depend on the user's skill level; results may vary.
This site participates in the Amazon Associate and Home Depot Affiliate programs, recommending suitable products and earning commission where appropriate.

Page updated

Report abuse